Home | TheWaterBlog

TheWaterBlog: If you want to share unique images and observations in this section, or would like to know about syndicating these posts, send an email to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.!

 

The Power of Peers: Community Certification 

by Frank van Steenbergen :: June 14, 2019

We have written earlier on the power of peers – a most powerful way of accelerating learning and identifying best practices.  By making people learn from each other and organizing competitions and treasure hunts among them, people are more convinced and confident that they can make the same change and even feel the urge to outperform others. (See blog: ‘The Power of Peers… , and Dossier ‘Video-centred Horizontal Learning

Put this horizontal learning against the classical vertical learning, where it is not uncommon for the teacher to keep his distance, have nothing to show for, and confuse the learner.  Horizontal learning on the other hand motivates and empowers, creates a common spirit for change – all intangibles that make a difference. Horizontal learning is also a great multi-plier: with its simple methods, outreach can be increased three or four-fold. 

The peer-to-peer processes of horizontal learning can be taken a step further by engaging it not just for learning but structuring it for peer reviews and community audits. Rather than having assessments done by external parties, peers evaluate each other and certify each other’s performances – whether in the areas of clean production, the absence of exploitation, proper sanitation, keeping areas free of pests, or any other. 

Vertical certification systems in fair trade or clean sourcing are notoriously expensive and cumbersome. They are the ‘Achilles heel’ of value chains. They take large parts of the costs and eat into the fair price and rewards to the producers following the good practice. As the bonus for the good practice for those in charge is minimized, an alternative has to be found. 

Bring in the peer-to-peer review. It is a practice that has been used with fabulous success and yet is still not fully exploited. It is common in quality control among professionals and in the inter-vision among coaches, but has also been used among senior government in Africa, who review each other’s policies in implementation of human rights, economic governance and resource management (see https://www.aprm-au.org). 

The peer-to-peer review process can be taken into the realm of community certification. Here neighbours and close peers review the performance of each other and officially certify whether the neighbour for instance produces organically, whether they have taken all measures to control rodents, whether they have safe sanitation practices, and more. 

How does it work? One can compare this to the system of micro-credit whereby peers stand guarantee for the creditworthiness of a lender without a physical collateral of her/his own. In community certification, neighbours using short factsheets assess the performance of one of their neighbours and assess whether she/he is meeting the criteria set. This is then part of a larger effort to declare the community free of pesticides, unhealthy practice, abuse, or other. 

The effects are multiple. Firstly, the awareness of good practice being talked about in a pleasantly compelling way. Peer- to-peer reviews help to set new norms and standard. Secondly, it creates the possibility and generates the effort to have an entire area certified by community engagement. This may help, for instance, get small producers into the bonus productions. It counters a trend whereby organic wholesalers either source their own supplies or work with large parties.  Thirdly, it sets up a more sympathetic system of accountability: with accountability geared primarily towards those near to us, and not to those far away who maybe disinterested in how we are and yet powerful.

  • Deforestation in Yemen’s Urban Areas – Sana’a University Campus as an example

    Deforestation in Yemen’s Urban Areas – Sana’a University Campus as an exampleBy Nada al-Dahmashi , Water and Environment Centre (WEC), Sana'a  University:: June 14, 2019Images: Nada al-Dahmashi The 1st of March is ‘Tree Day’ in Yemen. This annually reoccurring day was instated in 1975. It followed from a project that planned to have three million trees planted every year, and 9 millio...

    Read more

  • Man and ecology

    Man and ecology Postcard from Awezet, Farta (Amhara, Ethiopia)Posted by Frank van Steenbergen, Getachew Engdayehu, and Bantamlak Wondmnow June 05, 2019Located at the foot of the Guna Mountain in Amhara Region, life in Awezet has become gradually better over the last twenty five years. First it was the introduction of farm inputs, particularly fertilizers that caused crop yields to go up. The new...

    Read more

  • By a Glass of Water

    By a Glass of WaterPosted by Frank van SteenbergenMay 08, 2019 Remains of Queen of Sheba's palace in AxumAxum is a place of power and spirituality – and millennia of biblical history.The fabled Queen of Sheba came from this holy place in Northern Ethiopia.  Intrigued by the tales of the wisdom of King Solomon - that are still with us in the Proverbs -  she travelled to Jerusalem to meet her s...

    Read more

  • Vermiculture: Turkey’s new booming agro-business

    Vermiculture: Turkey’s new booming agro-business Posted by Sukru EsinApril 16, 2019A culture of dynamism and a entrepreneurship is enabling a variety of initiatives in Turkey. The agriculture sector in particular is very dynamic and open to new approaches. Vermicompost is a good example, that could be focused on more and replicated in different regions.In Turkey, the first vermicompost(solid an...

    Read more

  • Small blessings

    Small BlessingsBy Frank van Steenbergen, March 26, 2019On 22 March 2019 at the Sumatrakade in Amsterdam a delicate miracle happened. It rained in a small area of 15 metres length around two bare trees. The rest of the area remained entirely dry. It rained for twenty minutes and did not stop. Little pools formed on the old quai pavement and rain drops were falling into the pools. The sky was totall...

    Read more

  • Safe house. Postcard from Boschplaat, Terschelling.

    Safe house. Postcard from Boschplaat, Terschelling.By Frank van Steenbergen, March 19, 2019  The Safe house at Terschelling. (Credit left and right: Frank van Steenbergen. Middle: Jurjen Veerman Shutterstock)The North Coast of Terschelling Island, the Netherlands is the rough edge to what otherwise is one of the more smooth and caring countries of the world. It is an area with shifting sea shoal...

    Read more

  • The winter riddle

    The winter riddleFrank van Steenbergen | March 8, 2019  Here is the winter riddle. If one flies over a Northern winter landscape then there are large patches of snow covering town, villages, farmlands and water bodies whereas where there is forest there is hardly any. A pattern hidden in de warm days of the year is now revealed – white and dark green, open land and forest.So here is the riddle...

    Read more

  • Cherry trees, food, landscape

    Cherry trees, food, landscape by Frank van SteenbergenJanuary 15, 2019Postcard from Koblenz. Known for its mild climate and the wonderful winery that comes with it, the Upper Middle Rhine Region in Germany also harbours another secret – the cultivation of cherry trees with a 2000-year history. This area was the cherry capital of Germany, sourcing cherries throughout the region and hosting the l...

    Read more

  • Weapons against domestic violence

    Weapons against domestic violence by Frank van SteenbergenJanuary 4, 2018 Asked recently what good, improved agriculture brought to farming families on coastal Bangladesh, the answer among local farmer trainers was surprising: there is less domestic violence. The explanation is this: In the last 5 to 10 years, also due to projects such as the Blue Gold project in Bangladesh, there has been an u...

    Read more

  • Last day, Last drop

    Last day, Last drop Posted by Frank van Steenbergen December 31, 2018A woman in Bagh collecting water from a storage pond. Not just collecting but taking the very last bit of water. After this, the ‘thirst’ season starts. In Bagh (Pakistan), in the arid Kacchi Plains, it is hard to access fresh groundwater and there are no perennial rivers, so water availability depends on short bursts of floo...

    Read more