Home | TheWaterBlog

TheWaterBlog: If you want to share unique images and observations in this section, or would like to know about syndicating these posts, send an email to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.!

 

Watershed improvement: The upstream – downstream question

Frank van Steenbergen, Tesfa-alem Gebreegziabher Embaye and Eyasu Hagos 
April 14, 2017

If we utilize our water better upstream, what will happen downstream? Will water availability decrease? Is watershed improvement a zero-sum game with the gains upstream deducted from the situation downstream, or is it an overall system improvement? Or if we take a broader view of water-related ecosystems services, how does more intense upstream water use have an impact on all relevant ecosystem services in the entire area? Who are the winners and who are the losers? 

These are ‘everlasting questions’ that are seldom answered systematically with research. The WLE Harnessing Water for Food and Ecosystem Services project tried to answer them for flood and rain dependent areas (among others) in Ethiopia and Sudan. The research project combined field measurements, interviews with farmers, and a range of models. 

The project was implemented between January 2015 and December 2016, bringing together four organizations: the Spate Irrigation Network Foundation, the Hydraulic Research Centre (Sudan), Mekelle University (Ethiopia), and UNESCO-IHE (The Netherlands). 

In Ethiopia the research focused specifically on the Raya basin in the north. This basin harbors some of the most prominent flood-based livelihood systems with multiple competing uses and users. They are of substantial size, currently totaling to more than 90,000 hectares of cultivated area with a potential to expand four-folds. 

Within the Raya Basin in Ethiopia, two intensely cultivated sub-basins were compared: Guguf - with considerable improvement work having been done on its watershed-- and Oda –which had had only sporadic improvements. An indication of how the two compare is the fact that bench terraces, infiltration trenches, stone bund, terracing, grass strips, riparian measures and reforestation in Guguf covered more than twice the area they did in Oda. 

The research looked at a range of ecosystems service: run-off and water availability, but also the time and shape with which it comes in the downstream areas. Also observed was the amount of sediment and nutrients (P) retained within the upper catchment and the quantities exported downstream. Following  are the main findings:

  • The watershed treatment activities had considerable effect on the sediment transport. In Oda sub-catchment, the amount of sediment exported to the stream was much higher than Guguf sub-catchment (on average 44.2 and 4.8 t/ha/year respectively). The difference was largely explained by the watershed treatment activities, although given the shape of catchment the amount of potential soil loss in Oda is also higher. Similarly, nutrient retention was better in Guguf compared to Oda – but the difference was less pronounced: 1.03kg/ha/year against 0.97kg/ha/year on average. 
  • For Guguf catchment, where many watershed treatment activities were carried out, the volume of runoff produced is 15.3 mm from a rainfall of 144 mm, with the runoff coefficient being 10%.  For Oda watershed – the less treated one - the runoff produced is 145 mm but from a rainfall of 327mm only, in other words a runoff coefficient is around 35%. Further, a reduction of 46% in peak runoff is expected in Oda due to additional watershed treatment activities. For Guguf, the figure is 16%.  

A big question here was: what were the reduced runoff coefficient and peak runoff in Guguf translating into? Were they translating into increase in water availability for the downstream spate irrigation systems? The answer was: smaller quantities of water, but easier to use,  hence less uncontrollable flood peaks and more moderate spate. Also higher base flows and more springs. However, this was also a bit of a problem as it is relatively easy to capture base flows, which deprives the tail end users of the same.

The research also found that the ecosystems associated with water go ‘beyond water’. From farmer interviews, two important, often forgotten dimension of water were uncovered. The first is capillary rise – the upward movement of moisture – that takes place over a long period and feeds the root zone of the plants long after rain or flood events. It is related to the second dimension: the changes to micro-climate. By retaining more water in a part of a sub-basin, the entire local climate changes – fewer temperature peaks, more secure moisture, less drying out. 

So to answer the upstream-downstream question: good news! There is win-win rather than zero-sum. The increased upstream retention of run-off through better watershed management in the hilly sub-basin of Raya, does not lead to reduced overall water availability downstream. Flow patterns change though. They become more attenuated and more perennial. This brings a risk to downstream areas: that more of the now improved base flow is captured on the way. To add to the overall positive tally-sheet: watershed improvements produce many other ecosystem services – in particular reduced sedimentation transport and better buffered micro-climates.

             

  • Coastal Bangladesh: Roads to the Rescue?

    Roads to the RescuePosted by Cecilia BorgiaFebruray 8, 2017Coastal Bangladesh is a vast area. It encompasses 19 of the 64 Districts, 133 of the 484 Upazilas (sub-District), represents 32% of the country’s surface and hosts 28% of the national population. With its 1000 pp/km square, it is a very densely populated area. Despite the high risks of flooding, cyclones, and salinity intrusion making th...

    Read more

  • Getting a stronger rural economy

    Getting a stronger rural economyBy Frank van Steenbergen, Edris Hussien, Fredu Nega Tegebu and Letty Fajardo VeraMarch 23, 2017 It is a sign of an economy that is thin on the ground and not diversified – the number and composition of shops in rural Ethiopia or for that matter in many parts of Sub Saharan Africa. Non-farm business is limited in number and is ‘much of the same’.There are only...

    Read more

  • Somaliland: the camelback is broken

    Somaliland: the camelback is brokenBy James Firebrace and Frank van SteenbergenMarch 16, 2017  Famished camels cross barren landscape near Ballanbaal, late Nov 2016In an area dependent on thin and fragile rainfall disaster has arrived: drought, massive loss of livestock, just a straw away from famine. In the canon of the United Nations arid Somaliland officially does not exist. It is a self-decl...

    Read more

  • Life Skills – the missing foundation to improving socio-economic growth

    Life Skills – the missing foundation to improving socio-economic growthPosted by Otto HoffmanFebruary 15, 2017Image courtesy Wikimedia“Harvest to Poverty”The agricultural sector in many developing countries is facing innumerable challenges, thus requiring effective and vibrant extension services to improve agricultural productivity. Their economies depend on agriculture and employing a high ...

    Read more

  • A picture is worth a thousand words (although smell describes a thousand words, too)

    A picture is worth a thousand words (although smell describes a thousand words, too)Posted by Otto HoffmanFebruary 10, 2017The Bagmati River, which flows through the Kathmandu Valley of Nepal is regarded as a lifeline and as a source of Nepalese civilization and urbanization. The river flows through one of the holiest places in the country. Innumerable people from across South Asia, especially Ind...

    Read more

  • The largest battle for resilience

    The largest battle for resiliencePosted by Marta AgujetasFebruary 09, 2017The development army in Albuco Woreda, Amhara region, EthiopiaA battle takes place every year in Amhara, Ethiopia. The battle involves five million people, wielding shovels, axes and agricultural tools. Luckily, in this case people are not fighting each other, they are fighting their common enemy: land degradation. This five...

    Read more

  • Peri-urban water insecurity in the Kathmandu Valley, Nepal

    Peri-urban water insecurity in the Kathmandu Valley, NepalPosted by: Otto HoffmanFebruary 2017Nepal is known as the home of the Himalayas with innumerable streams and rivers, and snow-capped mountain peaks with permanent water resources. For all that, people are still lining up at water points – as residents of Kathmandu Valley are manually pumping water. So, some question what has caused this d...

    Read more

  • The Kenyan farmer who traveled his country

    The Kenyan farmer who traveled his country got inspired to harvest road water and is telling others to do the samePosted by Nienke HarmelinkJanuary 31, 2017Edward on his shamba with his wife and sister in lawAdopting road water harvesting Edward Ndolo lives just outside of Kitui town, located in the eastern part of Kenya. He is over 60 years old, a retired police officer and lives with his wife ne...

    Read more

  • Custody Continuity - the preservation success of the Maya Biosphere Reserve

    Custody Continuity - the preservation success of the Maya Biosphere ReservePosted by Frank van SteenbergenJanuary 27, 2017It has been run for twenty years now – the Maya Biosphere Reserve in Guatamala. As long as memory runs this forest has been the home of several indigenous Maya communities – whose entire lives and economy of hunting, fishing and collecting was part of it. Their custody con...

    Read more

  • Let the crisis not get hold of us: water supply in Yemen

    Let the crisis not get hold of us: water supply in YemenPosted by Taha AL-Washali, Frank van Steenbergen, Saroj Sharma, and Maria KennedyJanuary 25, 2017CollapseIn March, 2015, Saudi Arabia launched an aerial bombing campaign and naval blockade on Yemen. The initially limited war then scaled-up dramatically, destroying daily life in the poorest, most populous, and youngest nation in the Arabian Pe...

    Read more